home / subscribe / donate / books / t-shirts / search / links / feedback / events / faq


Down to the Wire

We’ve been telling you for three weeks that either we meet our fundraising goal of $75,000 or we'll be forced to cut back the operation of our website. More than a thousand of you have rallied with donations. Your response has been tremendous. Now, with only a week to go, we’re nearly there. Almost but not quite. And now we have just FIVE days to make our target.

The generous CounterPuncher who stepped forward with his pledge to match every donation of $100 or more, to a combined total of $20,000, is giving us a huge and vital assist. His offer is still open. Any of you out there thinking of donating $50 should know that if you donate a further $50, CounterPunch will receive an additional $100. And if you plan to send us us $200 or $500 or more, he will give CounterPunch a matching $200 or $500 or more.

Don’t miss the chance. Double your clout right now. Step up to the plate, and reach for the phone, or your check book or hit the online donation button.

In the new political era that began on November 3, CounterPunch will be offering its daily reality check. Many websites on the progressive side of the spectrum are cut-and-paste affairs, a mix of columns culled from mainstream newspapers, weeklies, blogs, tweets and so forth. Every day our CounterPunch site offers you up to a dozen original articles, and often twenty across our three-day weekend site.

We’ve been asking some of our readers and writers for our website to say why they value CounterPunch. Here’s what Noam Chomsky just wrote us:

“It is, regrettably, no exaggeration to say that we are living in an era of irrationality, deception, confusion, anger, and unfocused fear -- an ominous combination, with few precedents. There has never been a time when it was so important to have a voice of sanity, insight, understanding of what is happening in the world. Counterpunch has performed that essential service with unusual success. It is a matter of paramount importance to ensure that it will continue to do so, with even greater resources than before.”

And here’s Ralph Nader:

“A roaring colosseum of commentary, columnists and tell-it-like-it-was,-is,-and-should be original reportage, complete with a bookstore whose readable volumes tear away the lies, evasions, cover-ups and myths of a censored world. Taste, digest and deepen your mind from this fresh cornucopia called CounterPunch.”

Enough said. Please, use our secure server (now accepting PayPal) to make a tax-deductible donation to CounterPunch today or purchase a subscription and a gift sub for someone or one of our award-winning books (or a crate of books!) as holiday presents. (We won't call you to shake you down or sell your name to any lists--even Karl Rove's.)

To contribute by phone you can call Becky or Deva toll free at: 1-800-840-3683

Thank you, from Alex, Jeffrey, Becky, Alya, Deva, Kimberly and Marc.

 

Today's Stories

November 11, 2010

Peter Linebaugh
Laying Down Arms

November 10, 2010

Allan Nairn
US-Backed Death Squad Files Surface in Indonesia

Dean Baker
Wall Street's TARP Gang Rides Again: Now They're Coming After Your Social Security!

Nicola Nasser
Waiting for Godot in Palestine

Missy Beattie
Running Scared: My Colonoscopy Saga

Sergio Ferrari
Worrying Signs From Venezuela to Ecuador

Patrick Cockburn
Can Iraq's Leaders Do a Deal?

Dave Lindorff Mumia: New Lawyer, New Round

Sherwood Ross
How Affirmative Action Brought Willie Mays to the Giants

Joshua Frank
Sinking the Breakwater

Website of the Day
Stiglitz: "Throw the Bankers in Jail to Save the Economy"

November 9, 2010

Uri Avnery
Obama's Defeat

Mike Whitney
Bernanke's Dollar Policy

Jordan Flaherty
The Incarceration Capital of the US: the Crisis Inside New Orleans' Jails

Afshin Rattansi
Red Poppies

Annie Gell
Haiti's Unnatural Disasters

Dean Baker
The Fed's Second Shot

Dave Lindorff
BS From the BLS: Things are Much Worse Than They are Telling Us

Stewart J. Lawrence
The Nancy Monster That Refuses to Die

Walter Brasch
Love and Loss Among the Wild Horses

Website of the Day
Cut This: an Open Letter to the Tea Party

November 8, 2010

Paul Craig Roberts
Phantom Jobs

Thomas Healy
An Interview with Wendell Berry

David Swanson
A CIA Kidnapping in Milan

David Smith-Ferri
What Laila Sees

Ralph Nader
When Betrayed Voters Go to the Polls

Ray McGovern Torture Sans Regrets: Bush's Confessions

John Feffer
The Lies of Islamophobia

Christopher Ketcham
TV Toxicosis: What the Stewart / Colbert News Clowns Are Really Up To

Website of the Day
Sam Husseini Interrogates Rand Paul and Mike Pence

November 5 - 7, 2010

Alexander Cockburn
Now for the Good News

Vijay Prashad
Obama in India: a Tide of Turbans

Patrick Cockburn
If al-Qa'ida Really Want to Hit the West, They Can

Darwin Bond-Graham
Guess Who's Not Coming to Tea?

Mike Whitney
Dollar in the Dustbin

Linn Washington, Jr.
An Epidemic of Brutality: Oakland Filmmaker Feels Police Wrath

Rannie Amiri
STL = Sandbag the Lebanese

Ramzy Baroud
The Middle East's Stagnant "Change"

Larry Portis
Chou Sar? What Happened in Lebanon?

Gary Leupp
The Yemeni Toner Cartridge Bomb Story

William Loren Katz
Are Cruel Years Coming to a Neighborhood Near You?

Brian Cloughley
Spheres of Influence

Mark Weisbrot
The Fatal Mistake

Rubén M. Lo Vuolo, Daniel Raventós / Pablo Yanes
Basic Income in Times of Economic Crisis

Joseph Nevins
Ecological Privilege and the Frequent Flyer Activist

Neve Gordon
Thought Crimes

Alan Farago
The Bhopal Economy

Stewart J. Lawrence
Immigration Policy After the Midterm Elections

James R. King
The Other Side of Yemen

Ron Jacobs
How Ken Kesey Turned On America

Franklin Lamb
Israel Claims Victory in US Midterm Elections

James McEnteer
Beyond the Rational: the Alamo Election

Richard Phelps
Guy Fawkes and the Pressure of a Terrorism Spotlight

Saul Landau
Where's the Sanity Clause?

David Ker Thomson The Long Argument

Evelyn Pringle
The Vaccination Profiteers

Joseph G. Ramsey Until Pigs Fly: the Morning After With Michael Moore

Stanley Heller
Up Yours, John Stewart

Missy Beattie
The Big Universe

Harvey Wasserman
Vermont's Great Green Election Day Victory

Billy Wharton
Where Did Everybody Go?

Shamus Cooke
Democrats Run to the Right

Linh Dinh
War Games: Guns and Balls

Windy Cooler
Rallying Through This

Charles R. Larson
Witnesses of Haiti's History
: Edwidge Danticat's "Create Dangerously"

Phyllis Pollack
Keith Richards' Demon Life

David Yearsley
Bach and the Music of Time

Website of the Weekend
Smearing Jean-Luc Godard as an "Anti-Semite"

November 4, 2010

Doug Peacock
Desert Solitaire, Revisited

Andrew Cockburn
Why Summers Goes and Geithner Stays

Iain Boal
Crisis at Pacifica: the Two-Percent Putsch

Paul Craig Roberts
The Impotence of Elections

Chase Madar
Guantánamo: Exception or Rule?

Dave Lindorff
Take That You Smug Bastards!

Russell Mokhiber
Bought and Paid For

Laura Flanders
Lessons From Elizabeth Warren

Website of the Day
Moyers: the Howard Zinn Lecture

November 3, 2010

Alexander Cockburn
America the Clueless

Franklin C. Spinney
Democratic Debacle

Chris Floyd Dissatisfied Mind: Flickers of Hope in a Deadly Political Cycle

William Blum
Jon Stewart and the Left

Sheldon Richman
Provoking Yemeni Terrorism

Stephen Soldz
Fleecing Members, Colluding in Torture

Mark Weisbrot
Dilma's Victory in Brazil

Stewart J. Lawrence
Court Sends Mixed Signals on Arizona Immigration Law

Manuel Garcia, Jr. Election Night in Oakland

Norman Solomon
Now What?

Website of the Day
Save Our Social Security

November 2, 2010

Vincent Navarro
What's Happening in Europe?

Ishmael Reed
Brown Shirts, Black Shirts, T-Shirts

Uri Avnery
The Occupation and Political Corruption in Israel

Mark Driscoll
When the Pentagon "Kill Machines" Came to an Okinawan Paradise

Mike Whitney
Midterm Day of Reckoning: "Let the Landslide Begin"

Linh Dinh
Prone Pioneers: Punishing the Desperate for Being Desperate

David Macaray
Bring Back the Fifties! America's Most Misunderstood Decade

Randall Amster Wikilessons: War is a Joke, But It Isn't Funny

Betsy Ross
How the Banks Trumped Keynes

Yves Engler
A Sad Spectacle: Canada and the Jewish National Fund

Website of the Day
Gulf Oil Toxic to Humans

 

November 1, 2010

Ted Honderich
The Farce of Fairness

Steven Higgs
Don't Act Don't Sell: Why Liberals Will Get What They Deserve on Election Day

John Ross
A Ding-Dong Year for Death in Mexico

Dean Baker
A Darkening Future: Why Growth Still Feels Like a Recession

Ralph Nader
When Corporations are the Government

Justin E. H. Smith
The People Without History

Marjorie Cohn
Hyping Fear

Scott Boehm
Juan Williams and Katrina

Brian Tierney
The Struggle of DC's Nurses

Trish Kahle
Jon Stewart, Are You Really That Sane?

Martha Rosenberg Bathrobe Erectus: Feting Hugh Hefner

Website of the Day
Scary New Wage Data

 

October 29 - 31, 2010

Alexander Cockburn
Try (Just a Little Bit Harder)

Joe Bageant
Flatworm Economics

Peter Lee
China-Bashing Among the Elites

David Rosen
Class War in America

Mike Whitney
Bernanke Gets His Pink Slip

David Smith-Ferri Afghanistan: "Is This Normal?"

David Macaray Chamber of Horrors: Turbo-Lobbyists for the Ruling Class

Rannie Amiri
"Man Up," Juan Williams

Jonathan Cook
Protest Met With Rubber Bullets

Ramzy Baroud
Obama as a Salesman

Ellen Brown
Time for a New Theory of Money

Dr. Nina Pierpont
Wind Turbine Syndrome

Dave Lindorff
America's Happy News Media

Brian Horejsi
Mountain Biking in National Parks: a Sordid and Destructive Affair

Daniel Raventós Worldwide Concentration of Wealth: What the Figures Say

Richard Anderson-Connolly
Obama and the Politics of Misrule

David Thomson
Democracy is Effigy

Christopher Brauchli
It's the Muslims Fault!

Bob Fitrakis / Harvey Wasserman Charging Rove With Racketeering

Roberto Rodriguez Arizona Blues: a Time and Decade of Betrayal

Ron Jacobs
Vietnam's Revolution in the Revolution

Farzana Versey
Obama's Hawkish Policy in India

Michael Donnelly
Break Out the Clothespins: It's Voting Season

Gerald E. Scorse
Deficit Rises, Hypocrisy Rises Faster

John Grant
Xbox. vs. Wikileaks

Mickey Z.
When Criminals Vote ...

Charles R. Larson
Fear of Growing Up

Kim Nicolini
"Catfish": DIY Horror Film-making

Peter Stone Brown
The New Old Dylan

David Yearsley
Wagner v. the Machine

Poets' Basement
Davies, Ford and Clark

Website of the Weekend
CSPAN: Cockburn and St. Clair on Seattle WTO Protest and Beyond

 

October 28, 2010

Paul Craig Roberts
America's Job Losses are Permanent

Joseph Grosso
Wal-Mart and New York City

Kirkpatrick Sale
Getting Back to the Real Constitution?

Michael Winship
All They Ask For is an Unfair Advantage

Sherwood Ross
Gitmo's Indelible Stain: the Ordeal of Murat Kurnaz

Mark Weisbrot
Kirchner's Legacy: Rescuing Argentina; Uniting South America

Sam Smith Washington: Where Smart People Go to Do Stupid Things

Nicholas Arguimbau
Winning the War in Afghanistan at $50 Million per Kill

Sheldon Richman
Leaking the Truth

Franklin Lamb
Squeezing Hezbollah: Feltman's "Really Great Plan"

Website of the Day
The Anthropology of Garbage

October 27, 2010

Conn Hallinan
Money Wars

Michael Schwalbe
When Drones Come Home to Roost

Dave Lindorff
Obama's Black Site Prison: What are They Hiding at Bagram?

Gareth Porter
The Futile Surge

Dean Baker
An Economic Disaster

Clancy Sigal
The Sissy Left: Wimps Can't Win

Ram Etwareea
Why the Debt Crisis Hit Europe Harder Than the Emergent Countries of the South

Stewart J. Lawrence
Was Juan Williams "Lynched"?

Alan Farago
The Juan Williams Affair

Binoy Kampmark Offshoring Middle Earth: Prostituting the Hobbit

Website of the Day
Nature's Sting

 

October 26, 2010

Pam Martens
The Far Right's Secret Slush Fund to Keep Fear Alive

Joann Wypijewski
The Days of the Dead

Clarence Lusane Sold Brothers: the Bizarro World of Juan Williams and Clarence Thomas

Gareth Porter
The Futile Surge

Stephen Soldz
Iraq War Logs: Early Highlights

Lawrence Davidson
Ashcroft's Immunity and the Obama Administration

Alan Farago
The Florida Growth Machine

Dean Baker
The Abused Sibling

Jerica Arents
The Women's Harvest

Gerald E. Scorse Messing with Mankiw: Whining About Taxes and Work

Website of the Day
"A Project of Death and Destruction"

 

October 25, 2010

Nancy Scheper-Hughes
Body Parts and Bio-Piracy: Tissue, Skin and Organ Harvesting at Israel's National Forensic Institute

Patrick Cockburn
Echoes of El Salvador in US-Approved Death Squads

Kathy Kelly
"You're Not Alone"

Mike Whitney
Bernanke's Dilemma

Bill Quigley
The Class War at Home

Winslow T. Wheeler
How Many More Trillions for the Pentagon?

David Macaray
Sick Leave as National Policy

Stewart J. Lawrence
Latina "Mama Grizzly" Stalks Her Den

Ray McGovern
Honoring Julian Assange

Missy Beattie
Ginni and Clarence: Just Us at Home

Website of the Day
Please Vote for Washington Stakeout Today!

 

October 22 - 24, 2010

Alexander Cockburn
Your Money, Our Life

Lee Ballinger
After the Coal Rush: Music v. King Coal

Franklin C. Spinney
Memo to Obama: Three Strikes and You're Out

Rannie Amiri
Palestine's Olive Harvest Horror

Ralph Nader
Ten Questions for Tea Partiers

Laura Carlsen
Ecuador's Failed Coup: the Latin American Backlash

Avi Shlaim
Dishonest Broker: the US, Israel and Palestine

Mike Whitney
Thank God for France

Josh Stieber
An Iraq Surge Vet on Wikileaks

Kathy Kelly
"War Does This to Your Mind"

Sasan Fayazmanesh
The Left and Iranian Exiles

Conn Hallinan
Rising Tensions in the China Seas

Linn Washington, Jr.
The Ignored Dark-Sides of Joblessness

Christopher Brauchli
The Arms Sale Economy

Mark Weisbrot
Why French Protestors Have It Right

Stan Cox
"Nuke Them!" When Juan Williams Said Something Worse

Ramzy Baroud
The Violence Debate

Dave Lindorff
Arise, Ye Homeowners of America, You Have Nothing to Lose But Your Mortgages!

Benjamin Dangl
Ecuador's Challenge

Peter Stone Brown
Bob Dylan and America

Julie Hilden
High School Rumors and the First Amendment

David Ker Thomson
Bunker U

Missy Beattie
Owning the Shares of Shame

Suzy Dean
Ignoring the Social Benefits of Drinking

Charles M. Young
Crackpot Curriculum

M. Shahid Alam
A Dialectical Approach to the Qu'ran

Charles R. Larson
How to Destroy Your Marriage

David Yearsley
Learning and Lust in Berlin's New Library

Poets' Basement
José M. Tirado

Website of the Weekend
Help Bring Yoga into Prisons

October 21, 2010

Diana Johnstone
French Fury in the EU Cage

Joanne Mariner
A Glimpse into the Silicon Heart of the CIA's Drone Program

Mike Whitney
Bernanke's Biggest Problem: China as Collateral Damage

Lawrence Davidson
Invisible Israel?

Bill Quigley /
Laura Raymond
Artist Resistance in Honduras

Alan Farago
The Next Idiot Might Be You

David Smith-Ferri
Building Bamiyan Peace Park

Tolu Olorunda Educational Heroes and Myths

Website of the Day
Don't Just Deplore Bullying--Fight It!

October 20, 2010

Philippe Marlière
France Erupts: Sarkozy Under Siege

Tariq Ali
Red Hot France; Tepid Britain

Anthony Pahnke / Mark N. Hoffman
Digging Deeper: the San Jose Mine Disaster in Context

David Smith-Ferri
Bamiyan (Afghanistan) Diaries: Day One

Patrick Madden
QE2 and Foreclosures: Bank of America's Wager

Ishmael Reed
Professor Joe, Oakland's Next Mayor?

Dean Baker
Mortgage Mayhem

Mike Roselle
I'm Not Going Down Without a Fight

Dave Marsh
The Great General Johnson

Pete Redington
Dork is the New Cool

Website of the Day
The Poster Boy of Foreclosures

October 19, 2010

Pam Martens
The Koch Empire and Americans for Prosperity

Uri Avnery
The State of Bla-Bla- Bla

Ralph Nader
The Media and the Far Right

Clarence Lusane
From the White House to Obama's House: Race and Political Transition

Sherwood Ross
Union-Busting in Iraq

Trudy Bond
The Despot of Oklahoma: Mr. Coburn Goes to Haiti

Sherry Wolf
Our Not-So-Great Depression

Yves Engler
Why the UN Rejected Canada's Bid for the Security Council

Camilla Fox /
Chris Genovali
Killing Carnivores for Cash

Erin McManus
Hanoi Jane: War, Sex and Fantasies of Betrayal

Website of Day
Solar Done Right

October 18, 2010

Mike Whitney
How to Kickstart the Economy

Jonathan Cook
Settler Takeover of Israeli Police

Martha Rosenberg
The Return of Mad Cow Disease?

Stewart J. Lawrence
Does Jerry Brown's Campaign Have a Death Wish?

P. Sainath
The Narcissism of the Neurotic

James Zogby
Texas Takes a Dangerous Step Backwards

Ken Cole, Ralph Maughan / Brian Ertz
Governmental Disdain for Wolves

Patrick Brennan
Matt Taibbi's Epiphany: Dumping on the Tea Party

Jack Heyman
Justice for Oscar Grant! Jail for Killer Cops!

John Grant
Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Think

Website of the Day
Eating in Public

October 15 - 17, 2010

Alexander Cockburn
Daughters of the Gipper

Slavoj �i�ek
What is the Left to Do?

Paul Craig Roberts
The War on Terror: What's It All About?

Adrienne Pine /
David Vivar

Saving Honduras?

Peter Lee
The Detention of Xie Chaoping

Jonathan Cook
My Loyalty Oath

Bitta Mostofi
Admiring Ahmadinejad and Overlooking Activists

Franklin Lamb
On the Road with Ahmadinejad in Lebanon

Rannie Amiri
A Small Shove Back

Robert Alvarez
Nuclear Testing and the Rise of Thyroid Cancers

Joe Paff
Beyond Brown v. Whitman: the Late Great State of California

David Rosen
Sexy Sisters: the New Republican Women

David Correia
Greenwashing the Wal-Mart Way

Sam Hitchmough
Competing Americas: the Rise of the Tea Party

Ramzy Baroud
The Tide Has Changed

Dave Lindorff
Don't Act, Don't Lead: Obama Stiffs Gays in the Military Again

Graham Usher
Waiting on America

Gary Leupp
The Non-Jewish Immigration Loyalty Oath

David Macaray
In the Trenches of Union Politics

Ron Jacobs
Jimi Hendrix's "Machine Gun" and Obama's iPod

Peter Cervantes-Gautschi
Wall Street and the Criminalization of Immigrants

Lawrence Swaim
How Neo-Cons Became Honorary Christians

Linn Washington
Corporate Charter Schools Get the Cash

David Ker Thomson
Under Democracy

Norman Solomon
Progressive Canaries

Michael Dawson
Electric Evasions: the Green Car Con

John Stanton
Defense Contractors From Hell

Jayne Lyn Stahl
Leaving Las Vegas

Paul Buchheit
Stop the HURT

Ziad Abbas
Palestine: Without Water, There is No Life

Anthony Papa
Life for an $11 Robbery

Hardy Jones
New Threats to Dolphins: Toxins and Viruses

Missy Beattie
The Bedbug War: Nearly Helpless

Charles R. Larson
Fighting to End Africa's Worst Human Rights Crimes

Peter Stone Brown
Music Under the Radar

David Yearsley
Apollo's Fire

Poets' Basement
Moser & Rihn

Website of the Weekend
On This Earth

October 14, 2010

Mike Whitney
Bernanke Ponders the "Nuclear" Option

Jonathan Cook
The Transfer Scenario

Dean Baker
Globalizing Health Care

Marjorie Cohn
Israeli Raid on Gaza Flotilla: US Fails to Condemn, Despite UN Finding

Stewart J. Lawrence
Sex and the Orgasm Gap: Are Men Still Dominating Women in Bed?

Carl Finamore
San Francisco's Hotel Frank(enstein): a Horror Show for Employees

Dave Lindorff
9 Million Stolen Homes: Getting Tough on Banker Crime

Raúl Zibechi
Brazil's Elections: the Continuation of Lulismo

Willie L. Pelote
Shock Therapy for California?

Website of the Day
Can Mushrooms Rescue the Gulf?

October 13, 2010

Vijay Prashad
The Waning of Obama

Uri Avnery
His Father's Son: the Real Bibi

Dean Baker
The Counterfeit Recovery

Winslow T. Wheeler
Where is the Payoff for Huge Pentagon Budget Hikes?

Patrick Bond
"To Exist is to Resist:" From Apartheid South Africa to Palestine

Michael Winship
Cash You Can Believe In

Myles B. Hoenig
Are We Expendable? An Education Manifesto From the Trenches

Tom Turnipseed
Money Talks (and Swears)

Website of the Day
The Return of Ben Tripp, as Zombie Novelist

October 12, 2010

Ralph Nader
Tricks and Traps in the Fine Print

Franklin C. Spinney
Techno War: Money Talks, Counter-measures Walk

Mike Whitney
The Future is Ugly

Robert Alvarez
The Tritium Deficit

Deepak Tripathi
India's High Stakes Foreign Policy

Chris Genovali / Camilla Fox
Death Cults Among Us: the War on Wolves

Harvey Wasserman
Calvert Cliffs on the Brink

Robert Jensen
Soils and Souls: the Promise of the Land

Mark Weisbrot
How to Change the IMF

Charles R. Larson
America's Religious Veneer

Website of the Day
How You Can Help Fund Radical Grassroots Green Groups (and Double Your Money)

 

October 11, 2010

Michael Hudson
Why the U.S. Has Launched a New Financial World World War

Bill Quigley
A Million Haitians Slowly Dying

Linn Washington
American Justice on Trial

Paul Krassner
Eat, Pray, Be Disappointed: an Open Letter to Obama

Jonathan Cook
Israel's Other "Peace" Plan

Cal Winslow
Big Money, the Big Lie and Fear

Sherry Wolf
Why are Liberals Building the Right?

Peter Stone Brown
Brother Solomon Burke

David Michael Green
How Do You Take Your Tea?

Jayne Lyn Stahl
Disclose This

Website of the Day
"Seize the Jail! Tear It Down!!"

October 8 - 10, 2010

Alexander Cockburn
The Soros Syndrome

Paul Craig Roberts
America's Third World Economy

Alain Gresh
What Does a "One State Solution" Really Mean?

Patrick Cockburn
Is Pakistan Falling Apart?

Rannie Amiri
An Evaporating Palestine

Conn Hallinan
Ecuador: Coup or Riot?

Ramzy Baroud
Dying to Win

Saul Landau
Harboring Terrorists

Sam Smith
What's Missing in the Talk About Education Reform

Yvonne Ridley
On the Road to Damascus, Thinking of Monty Python

Ellen Brown
Foreclosuregate: a Massive Fraud

Santwana Dasgupta
A View From the Top of the World

David Macaray Labor Secretaries: Frances and Elaine

Gerald E. Scorse
Tax System Favors Wealth Over Work

Tony Newman
The Perils of Prohibition

David Ker Thomson
Soundtrack for a Beating

Christopher Brauchli
Authentic Dishonesty: Newt and Dinesh Save America!

Jon Mitchell
Oliver North, Ospreys and Agent Orange

Kevin Zeese
The Longest War

Steven Best
Rethinking Revolution

Missy Beattie
Invasion of the Blood-Sucking Bedbugs

Binoy Kampmark
England's Football Inc.

Charles R. Larson
Egypt's Camus?

Kim Nicolini
"Social Network:" Narcissism and Claustrophobia Among the Techno-Elites

Dave Marsh
"American Idiot:" Finally, a Musical That Rocks

David Yearsley
The Dark Side of Musical Enlightenment

Poets' Basement
Three by Peter Branson

Website of the Weekend
Help the Great Michael Fracasso Revolutionize the Music Industry

 

Share/Bookmark

November 11, 2010

Cars for the Elite

Obama's Electric Vehicle Fetish

By ROBERT BRYCE

Imagine an American president who, during a press conference, extols the importance of cars made by Mercedes Benz or BMW. The reaction, particularly on Fox News, is easily envisioned: outraged cries of “elitist” and “out of touch” would persist for days or even months afterward.

That, in essence, is exactly what President Barack Obama did last Wednesday. Obama acknowledged the thumping that the Democrats took at the polls on November 2, and went on to discuss the need for more all-electric vehicles, at one point saying “There's a lot of agreement around the need to make sure that electric cars are developed here in the United States.”

Fine. Both Mercedes and BMW manufacture cars in the U.S. But here are two essential points: Those two automakers each control about the same percentage of the domestic car market that automotive analysts believe electric cars will have by 2020. Second, and perhaps more important: the same people who buy Benzes and Beemers – the wealthy – are the ones most likely to buy a new electric car.

Obama’s electric vehicle fetish reflects much of the inanity of our discussions about energy. The idea that oil is bad, and that we must therefore throw vast sums of money at efforts aimed at fueling our automotive fleet with something else – anything else – ignores both economic realities and the myriad problems inherent with EVs.

First, the economic realities. Earlier this year, Deloitte Consulting released a report on EVs which found that the most likely buyers are people with household incomes “in excess of $200,000” and “who already own one or more vehicles.” Furthermore, Deloitte expects those buyers to be “concentrated around southern California where weather and infrastructure allow for ease of EV ownership.”

Deloitte concluded that the US now has about 1.3 million consumers who “fit the demographic and psychographic profiles” of expected EV buyers. It went on, saying that mass adoption of the EV “will be gradual” and that by 2020, perhaps 3 percent of the US car market could be amenable to EVs. The report also says that the keys to “mass adoption are 1) a reduction in price; and 2) a driving experience in which the EV is equivalent to the internal combustion engine.”

Think about those numbers. Out of 300 million Americans, perhaps 1.3 million of them – with many of those living in areas in or around Los Angeles and San Diego -- are likely to buy an EV.

Deloitte’s projections are exactly the same as those recently put forward by Johnson Controls Inc., a company that makes batteries for cars and is building two new plants in order to supply the EV market. Last month, the Wall Street Journal reported that Johnson Controls’ research “found that the pool of US customers for whom an electric car makes financial sense – those who travel many miles a year, but on short trips – is very small, about three percent of drivers.”

Hmmm. Three percent of drivers? In both 2009 and 2010, Mercedes and BMW each controlled about 2 percent of the US auto market.

Why will EVs be playthings for the rich? The answer is simple: the history of the EV is a century of failure tailgating failure. Consider this quote: In 1911, the New York Times declared that the electric car “has long been recognized as the ideal solution” because it “is cleaner and quieter” and “much more economical” that gasoline-fueled cars.

Whenever you hear about the wonders of the new hybrid-electric Chevrolet Volt, which at $41,000 per copy costs as much as a new Mercedes-Benz C350, consider this assessment by a believing reporter: “Prices on electric cars will continue to drop until they are within reach of the average family.” That line appeared in the Washington Post on Halloween, 1915.

And since the Volt is being built by GM, ponder this news item which declared that the carmaker has found “a breakthrough in batteries” that “now makes electric cars commercially practical.” The batteries will provide the “100-mile range that General Motors executives believe is necessary to successfully sell electric vehicles to the public.” That story was published in the Washington Post on September 26, 1979.

The problem today is the same as it was in 1911, 1915, and 1979: the paltry  energy density of batteries. On a gravimetric basis, gasoline has 80 times the energy density of the best lithium-ion batteries. Of course, electric-car supporters will immediately retort that electric motors are about four times more efficient than internal combustion engines. But even with that four-fold advantage in efficiency, gasoline will still have 20 times the energy density of batteries. And that is an essential advantage when it comes to automobiles, where weight, storage space, and of course, range, are critical considerations.

Despite the all-electric automobile’s long history of failure, despite the fact that EVs will likely only be driveway jewelry for the wealthy, the Obama administration is providing more than $20 billion in subsidies and tax breaks for the development and production of cars that use electricity instead of oil.  

Indeed, the administration keeps throwing money at EVs despite a January 2009 report published by the Department of Energy’s Office of Vehicle Technologies, which said that despite the enormous investments being made in plug-in hybrid-electric vehicles and lithium-ion batteries, four key barriers stand in the way of their commercialization: cost, performance, abuse tolerance, and life. The key problem, according the DOE analysts, was—predictably—the battery system. The report concludes that lithium-based batteries, which it calls “the most promising chemistry,” are three to five times too expensive, are lacking in energy density, and are “not intrinsically tolerant to abusive conditions.”

Remember when Barack Obama, the presidential candidate, berated the Bush administration for not paying attention to the science? In December 2008, shortly after being elected to the White House, he declared, “It's time we once again put science at the top of our agenda and worked to restore America's place as the world leader in science and technology."

Restoring America’s leadership in science and technology is a worthy goal. But by attempting to pick winners in the car business -- arguably the world’s single most competitive industry -- the Obama administration is forgetting  history and the panoply of problems that have kept EVs in the garage since the days of Thomas Edison. It’s time to unplug this subsidy-dependent industry and let the free market work.

Robert Bryce’s latest book is Power Hungry: The Myths of “Green” Energy and the Real Fuels of the Future.

 

 

CounterPunch Print Edition Exclusive!

CLASS WAR IN THE U.K. AND FRANCE

Susan Watkins, editor of New Left Review, reports on Britain’s Tri-partisan Electoral Monolith and how the Slash-and-Burn Tory Coalition is picking up from where New Labour left off. Larry Portis reports from France on the mass protests and the shrivelling of Sarkozy.  Peter Lee gives us an rivetting piece on the awful tragedy of China’s Yellow River.
Subscribe now! If you find our site useful please: Click here to make a donation. CounterPunch books and t-shirts make great presents.
Order CounterPunch By Email For Only $35 a Year !
    

 

    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Now Available from CounterPunch Books!

Wasting Libby:
the True Story of How the WR Grace Corporation Left a Montana Town to Die (and Got Away With It)

By Andrea Peacock
Introduction by Jeff Bridges



How the Economy
Was Lost
By Paul Craig Roberts

Yellowstone Drift:
Floating the Past
in Real Time

by John Holt
Introduction by Doug Peacock


Born Under a Bad Sky:
Notes from the Dark Side

of the Earth
By Jeffrey St. Clair

Waiting for Lightning
to Strike:
The Fundamentals

of Black Politics
Kevin Alexander Gray

Click Here to Buy!

"The Case Against Israel"
Michael Neumann's Devastating Rebuttal of Alan Dershowitz

Click Here to Buy!

RED STATE REBELS:
Tales of Grassroots Resistance from the Heartland

Edited by
Jeffrey St. Clair
and Joshua Frank


How the Press Led
the US into War


Buy End Times Now!
The Secret Language
of the Crossroads:
HOW THE IRISH
INVENTED SLANG
By Daniel Cassidy
WINNER OF THE
AMERICAN BOOK AWARD!


Click Here to Buy!

The Inside Story of the Shannon Five's Smashing Victory Over the
Bush War Machine

By Harry Browne


Saul Landau's Bush and Botox World with a Foreword by Gore Vidal

Click Here to Order!

 Grand Theft Pentagon
How They Made a Killing on the War on Terrorism

Spell Albuquerque:
Memoir of a
"Difficult Student"

By Tennessee Reed

 

 

 

"Powerful and shocking ..
see this film"
-- Joseph Stiglitz on American Casino

 

  

 

 


The Occupation
by Patrick Cockburn

  
Humanitarian Imperialism
By Jean Bricmont
 
  
CITY BEAUTIFUL
By Tennessee Reed
      

OSZAR »